Introduction
Susan When She Tried: A Song of Determination and Heartbreak
“Susan When She Tried” might not be one of The Statler Brothers’ biggest hits, but it holds a curious place in their discography and has sparked questions among fans. Here’s what we know about the song’s history:
Authorship: Don Reid, one of the founding members of The Statler Brothers, wrote “Susan When She Tried.” There’s no definitive information on the year it was written, but it appeared on their 1975 album “Sons of the Motherland.”
The Mystery of Susan: The identity of Susan remains a mystery. There’s speculation that the name might be a placeholder used during the songwriting process, or perhaps inspired by someone Don Reid knew. Some fans have even theorized it’s a reference to figure skater Peggy Fleming, though there’s no evidence to support this.
The Song Itself: The lyrics tell the story of a woman named Susan who sets her mind to something and gives it her all, but ultimately faces heartbreak. The song doesn’t delve into the specifics of what Susan “tried,” but the emotions of determination, struggle, and disappointment are clear. The catchy melody and signature Statler Brothers harmonies make it a relatable and enjoyable listen, despite the bittersweet theme.
Chart Performance: “Susan When She Tried” wasn’t a chart-topping single for the group, but it became a fan favorite for its emotional depth and storytelling.
So, while the exact origin story of “Susan When She Tried” remains a bit fuzzy, the song itself is a testament to the power of perseverance and the sting of unfulfilled dreams. It’s a reminder that giving our all doesn’t always guarantee success, but the effort itself can be a source of strength.
This introduction sets the stage for listening to the song, piquing your curiosity about Susan and her story. Whether you connect with the determination she embodies or the heartache she experiences, “Susan When She Tried” offers a relatable glimpse into the human experience.