Introduction
“He’s Just Getting Started”: The Heartwarming Journey of American Idol Runner-Up John Foster
The remarkable journey of John Foster to becoming the runner-up on American Idol 2025 is more than just a story about a young man with a golden voice. It is a moving portrait of perseverance, family devotion, and deep-rooted authenticity. Hailing from a small town in Louisiana, John’s soft-spoken nature and classic country charm quickly won over audiences across the country. But behind the scenes, his rise was shaped by years of effort—and the steadfast love and sacrifices of his family.
In a candid appearance on Unfiltered with Kevin, John’s mother, Amanda Benoy, opened up about the lesser-known struggles and triumphs along the way. She revealed that John’s Idol dreams began in 2021, during the height of the pandemic. His first audition, held via Zoom, ended in disappointment, but it only fueled his passion. “He didn’t make it past the open call,” Amanda recalled, “but he never gave up.”
It wasn’t until his third attempt in 2025 that John’s talent finally found the spotlight it deserved. Amanda shared how close he came to being overlooked again—until Carrie Underwood, a guest judge, fought to keep him in the competition. She praised his timeless sound, calling his voice “a beautifully rare throwback in today’s country music.”
Yet perhaps the most emotional detail Amanda shared was the sacrifice made by John’s older sister, Elizabeth. Just two and a half years his senior, Elizabeth postponed her wedding to be in the audience every week, cheering her brother on in Los Angeles. “She’s his number one cheerleader,” Amanda said tearfully, “besides me.”
This unshakable bond between siblings anchored John through emotional performances, including a heartfelt tribute to a late friend that left many—including Carrie Underwood—visibly moved. After Idol, John relocated to Nashville to pursue his music full-time. At just 19, he’s already graced the stage of the Grand Ole Opry.
John Foster’s story is more than a rise to stardom—it’s a testament to family, faith, and grit. With his family behind him and his roots still grounded, one thing is certain: he’s just getting started.