Introduction
The Statler Brothers and “The Great Pretender”: A Cover Story
While The Statler Brothers’ version of “The Great Pretender” is a beloved country classic, the song’s origins lie in the world of doo-wop and R&B.
The true “Great Pretender” was penned in 1955 by Buck Ram, the manager and producer for the vocal group The Platters. Legend has it that Ram wrote the song in a mere 20 minutes, aiming to capitalize on the group’s recent success with “Only You (And You Alone)”. His gamble paid off. The Platters’ version, featuring Tony Williams’ soaring vocals, topped the Billboard Hot 100 and became a doo-wop staple.
The song’s universal themes of longing and putting on a facade resonated with audiences beyond R&B. Over the years, “The Great Pretender” has been covered by a wide range of artists, from soul legend Sam Cooke (whose version is believed to have inspired the band The Pretenders’ name) to rock icon Freddie Mercury.
The Statler Brothers entered the picture sometime in the 1960s or 70s. While the exact date of their recording is unclear, their rendition took the song in a new direction. Their signature close harmonies and country instrumentation transformed “The Great Pretender” into a relatable ballad for country music fans.
The Statler Brothers’ version found a home on several of their compilation albums, including the aptly titled “Sing the Classics.” While not a chart-topping hit for them, it has become a cherished part of their repertoire, a testament to the enduring power of a great song that can be successfully reinterpreted across genres.
So, as you listen to The Statler Brothers’ version of “The Great Pretender,” remember that you’re experiencing a song with a rich history, one that started in the world of doo-wop and continues to resonate with country music fans today.