Introduction
“You Can’t Have Your Kate and Edith Too” by The Statler Brothers is a classic country song that showcases the group’s signature blend of humor, storytelling, and harmonies. Released in 1967, the song was part of their album Sing the Big Hits, which contributed to their rise in popularity in the country music scene. Known for their ability to craft songs that are both witty and relatable, The Statler Brothers delivered a track that resonated with audiences for its clever wordplay and catchy melody.
The Statler Brothers, consisting of Harold Reid, Phil Balsley, Jimmy Fortune, and Don Reid, were renowned for their tight harmonies and storytelling prowess. The group originally hailed from Staunton, Virginia, and started their musical journey in the 1950s. Their unique sound and approach to country music quickly set them apart from their contemporaries. The Statler Brothers were initially associated with Johnny Cash, as they opened for his shows and performed as his backing vocalists, which helped them gain significant exposure.
“You Can’t Have Your Kate and Edith Too” exemplifies the group’s penchant for creating songs with humorous and often tongue-in-cheek lyrics. The song tells the story of a man caught between two women, Kate and Edith, and humorously highlights the complications and dilemmas that arise from trying to juggle relationships with both. The clever title itself is a play on the phrase “You can’t have your cake and eat it too,” which means one cannot enjoy both of two desirable but mutually exclusive alternatives.
The song was well-received by fans and critics alike for its humor and catchy tune. It became a staple in the Statler Brothers’ live performances, showcasing their ability to entertain audiences with lighthearted and engaging material. The song’s success helped solidify the Statler Brothers’ reputation as one of the premier vocal groups in country music, known for their versatility and ability to craft songs that ranged from comedic to deeply emotional.
Throughout their career, The Statler Brothers continued to release a string of hits that demonstrated their unique blend of humor, nostalgia, and emotion. They earned numerous awards, including several Grammy Awards and Country Music Association (CMA) Awards, and were inducted into the Country Music Hall of Fame in 2008.
“You Can’t Have Your Kate and Edith Too” remains a memorable part of the Statler Brothers’ discography, celebrated for its wit and the way it encapsulates the group’s distinctive style. The song is a testament to their talent for storytelling and their ability to connect with listeners through relatable and entertaining lyrics. As part of their early catalog, it helped pave the way for the many successes that followed in their illustrious career.